Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Joseph Friedman's avatar

Years ago I read of the distinction between intellect and intelligence. Intellect only asks "how". Intelligence asks "why". This distinction is akin to Iain MacGhilrist's description of the differing functions of the left and right hemispheres of the brain. The Large Language Model concatenations labelled AI is not and cannot be intelligent. It is a massive amplification and acceleration of our left brain, of our intellect. My prayer is that its sudden, even violent insertion into our lives will highlight what is uniquely ours to do: to love, pray, care and be present, in a way an AI agent or robot can never be, and have humans embrace our unique capabilities and use them to constrain this technology and the massive forces that are insinuating it into world without caution.

Elizabeth Macaulay's avatar

I feel so strongly that crafting sermons and pastoral reflections is the stuff of poetry and soul, not AI. To surrender that work to the great electronic collective while canibalizing the unpaid work of other poets and theologians feels like both the creator of the work and the recipient of the work are being shortchanged.

12 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?